
Cityrub Steak & Smokehouse
118 Stockton St, Newark, NJ 07105
About Cityrub Steak & Smokehouse - steak house in Newark, New Jersey
Late-night lounge for cocktails & dancing, with rotating roster of DJs, plus Latin nights.
Customer Review Summary
Cityrub Steak & Smokehouse has received mixed reviews from customers. Positive comments highlight the delicious food, great atmosphere, and live music. Recommendations include the salmon with passion fruit sauce, turkey cheeseburger, brisket, and various cocktails. The outdoor dining area is praised for its decor and cleanliness. Negative feedback focuses on poor service and issues with food quality. Several diners reported slow service, incorrect orders, and cold dishes. Some found the food lacked flavor or was improperly prepared, such as the overly salty ribs and undesired sauce on the burger. Complaints about high prices not reflecting food quality and service issues were common. Overall, while some enjoyed their experience, many others were disappointed and expressed concerns about service and food consistency.
Key Features
Service options
- Outdoor seating
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Highlights
- Fast service
- Great beer selection
- Great cocktails
- Live music
- Sports
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible restroom
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Alcohol
- Beer
- Cocktails
- Coffee
- Comfort food
- Happy hour drinks
- Happy hour food
- Hard liquor
- Late-night food
- Quick bite
- Small plates
- Vegetarian options
- Wine
Dining options
- Brunch
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Dessert
- Seating
Amenities
- Bar onsite
- Restroom
Atmosphere
- Casual
- Cozy
- Trendy
Crowd
- Groups
- Tourists
Planning
- Accepts reservations
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Children
- Good for kids
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
Parking
- Free parking lot
- Free street parking
Pets
- Dogs allowed outside
Customer Reviews
Rating Distribution
Andrea Olguin
First time visiting this place for a nice dinner and live band. The Pagode band was amazing, food delicious, great atmosphere. I highly recommend the salmon with passion fruit sauce. Yummy š
Kara Cowley
The staff must have been having an off night or something when we were here. Decided to try it out because the food and reviews looked good but our experience was the opposite. Our server took a looooooong time to come over to us when we sat down, took our drink and food order, came back with one drink instead of two and forgot our waters we ordered, and when the food came out it was not hot. The Mac n cheese we ordered was cold cold and we asked to have it reheated. Mind you we were there on a Monday night and aside from one 10 top table, the place was completely empty. Thereās no reason anything should have been forgotten or served cold. I am a waitress myself and I can tell the server we had just simply did not give a f. He was very nonchalant, and as someone who works in the food industry that really bothers me. This was the first time in my life Iāve left less than a 20% tip. The one other woman working there was very friendly and even offered to give my almost 2 year old some balloons to blow up and play with. Overall the atmosphere and interior design of the restaurant is really cool! I can imagine this being a fun spot to go to on a Friday night. My. Husband got a brisket sandwich and I got the pastrami sandwich, which was good but the Gouda that comes in it is overpowering and I eventually took it off so I could actually taste the rest of the flavors. My husband also woke up in the middle of the night throwing up and spent the next day on the toilet and heās feeling pretty positive it was the food.
samone jones
So first I'm going to give my pros about the restaurant. I went in and placed my order for the turkey cheeseburger, some smoked wings, coconut shrimp, half a slab of ribs and smoked potato salad. When I finally got home I looked at the turkey cheeseburger and it looked delicious and even taste even better I will definitely be ordering that again. I waited to have the wings and coconut shrimp the next day because I was full. The wings weren't bad I could have had a little sauce on them other than that they were tasty. The shrimp more tasty but I could have had a little bit more than four for that price. My mom really didn't like the smoked potato salad she said it didn't have any smoke flavor in it and she said those ribs could have been better. She said the ribs were tender on one end and tough on the other.
Matthew Mc Donald
For the price the food was not great, no flavour in the meat, felt it was smoked a while ago, and left to get dry and loose its flavour. I asked what is recommended and the waitress was not to sure how to sell anything. Donāt recommend, in 2017 apparently Forbes said you canāt best their meat, I can honestly say that the quality of food needs to improve
Renee Sales
You have to visit ! Its so delicious! They never disappoint. Best drinks ever! Coconut mojito & strawberry margaritas, moonshime shots ate bomb! Cheery, peach and apple is my favorite. Excellent service and beautiful outdoor dinning area. Always decorated for the occasion/ holiday. Servers are constantly attentive to you needs while dinning there. Restroom are clean and women's bathroom is decorated for selfie pics. Honey corn bread is rich and delicious. Tacos are fresh, seasoned very well. You can get fish, brisket or pulled pork. Their brisket is the best! Also not busy, pleanty of seating and parking on site. Steak coojed as you request with asparagus, potato wedges, mashed potatoes. Good kids options with right sized portions. Burgers are juicy and tender full of flavor with their tasty bacon jam.
Rennie Wilson
This review is to the owner, Your place is beautiful ur location sucks. Your drinks are excellent. Your service is below standard and your BBQ isn't on point. With all that being said with my experience in the industry. you need my help. I would hate to see this beautiful place close. If interested reach out. I'm sure ur profits aren't where they should be
alanis condors
Today, I had an incredibly disappointing experience at a restaurant called City Rub in Newark, NJ. I ordered the ādouble cheeseburgerā and confirmed with the waiter that it was plain, as stated in the menu, which described it as including only cheese, slab bacon, baby arugula, and fries. However, when the dish arrived, it contained a sweet, tangy sauce they referred to as ābacon jam,ā which I had neither requested nor was listed on the menu. When I brought this to the waiterās attention, he insisted thatās how the burger is prepared, despite the menu's description. I sent the dish back, as I had no intention of eating something I didnāt order, yet they still charged me for it. Instead of addressing their mistake or offering a resolution, the staff blamed me and left me responsible for the cost of an uneaten meal. To make matters worse, the waiter claimed the management would ātake it out of his tips,ā showcasing an appalling way to treat both customers and employees. The entire ordeal was a reflection of terrible service and management practices, and I will not be returning to this establishment.
Neo W
This was nice. Appitizers: The calamari was way better the first time we came, this time it was mostly the crisp. The spicy Thai shrimp was pretty good. Food: I had Bronzino with roasted potatos, asparagus, and tomatoes. There were too many capers in it, but was over all cooked nicely. The staff was friendly and attentive. Drink: Coolcumber (Gin cocktail) was pretty refreshing. I do think the drinks were far too expensive for the size, but that's a NJ thing I guess. The drink was well flavored. Both drinks in the photo are the same. One with ice one without. Exact same drink. There is live music which is really nice and folks dancing and enjoying it. 20% Gratuity is included and they do not inform you of this ahead of time. This is unfortunate as I don't think the service deserves a $41 dollar and change tip in the slightest. I would have 100% tipped 15% but 20% was reaching and not too deserved.
Location
Contact Information
Hours of Operation
Price Range
More Steakhouses in Newark

Fernandes Steak House II
158 Fleming Ave, Newark, NJ 07105
Diners eat until they're stuffed at this lively Brazilian grill serving an endless parade of meats.

Dayton Steakhouse Bar & Grill
278 Dayton St, Newark, NJ 07114

5 Star Steak House
110 Jabez St, Newark, NJ 07105

Medallion Steakhouse & Seafood
50 Park Pl, Newark, NJ 07102